I think my answer will be clear enough by the end of this, but first let me say: this cute little 'STANDUP Act' can go to hell.
At sixteen, I did a
lot of driving that would violate their 'agreement'. I drove at night - sometimes picking up a friend at work, sometimes taking a long (and yes, horribly wasteful) 'therapy drive' so we could talk about our troubles in a non-public, neutral zone (and feel like we were getting away from them, just for a while). That would have been two counts against me, probably two or three times a week for two years.
As for the daytime passenger restrictions - I don't even know what they are. I could Google to find out, I'm sure, but as it's not on the linked page's rundown (which, btw, I couldn't find until I clicked to
sign the petition to support it) ... clearly Allstate would rather I didn't. I rather doubt it tips its hat to teens who want to carpool to or from school, though.
So I want to find some snarky wrap-up, but really this boils down to me not being able to imagine what my adolescence would have been like if this type of graduated licensing had been in place back then. I would have ignored it, probably, and had even less respect for traffic laws than I did have (see: perfect teen driver - not, below). Or maybe I would have bowed to the threat of hassle and obeyed: saved some money, left the occasional stranded friend to walk home, and seen friends who lived more than a mile away rarely (if ever, aside from school). Been lonelier, because I sure as hell didn't feel isolated
enough ... what teenager does, right?
I wasn't the perfect teen driver, and I won't pretend that I was. On the other hand, I never had a moving violation; nobody I let into my car came out injured. Some of that was luck. And frankly, it would have been fantastic to live in a city with really developed public transit - but I sure as hell don't see Allstate addressing the root problems here, or even nodding to the parts of modern life that made us into a society where sixteen-year-olds would, in fact, really need to drive.